City Island is an isolated community that requires the response of all companies, except 70 & TL 53, to cross one or two bridges to reach the 1 1/2 mile long by 1/2 wide community. It looks like an old New England fishing community made up of residential buildings, marina's, & restaurants. Most of the older buildings are frame (wood) constructed & can range up to 4 or 5 stories high. I think that an apartment house on the bay side of the island is the highest on the island. Its either 6 or 7 stories high brick & located on Pilot St. This was the site of a line of duty death for an officer of Engine 70.
Years back, before 66 & L61 were established the units responding units to City Island would take different routes. Eng 97 would use the Hutchinson River Pkwy while 89 & L50 responded along the Bruckner Service Rd. Since these companies had to cross two different draw bridges, there was an agreement that only one bridge could open at a time. This way help could always reach the island. Companies like 38 & TL51 can respond into lower Westchester Co. cross over to Shore Rd & head south toward City Island.
The last response problem was crossing a swing bridge that leads you onto the island. In recent years that bridge no longer can open & there is talk of it being replaced in the near future.
City Is. has seen its share of multiple alarm fires over the year. When the Superpumper was in service, the system was assigned to respond on the second alarm. Today Sat # 2 is assigned on either the 10-75 (working fire) or 7-5 (All Hands) so that a good water supply can be established. There was a story that they used the superpumper at a fire there once, but it damaged alot of the local plumbing. After that FDNY would announce hookup sites for the system to use so that a water supply could be maintained.