NYCs 2019 elections were a loss for law abiding NYC Citizens & a boost for the lawless.......wsj.com
New Queens, N.Y., Prosecutor Pledges Changes to a Law-and-Order Office
Corinne Ramey
6-8 minutes
Queens? next top prosecutor, Melinda Katz, has pledged to bring a left-leaning approach to criminal justice in her new job, a challenge in an office that has long been known for its traditional law-and-order policies.
Ms. Katz, a Democrat, was elected on Tuesday as the borough?s district attorney with 75% of the vote in a decisive victory over Republican candidate Joe Murray, a police-officer-turned-prosecutor who supported more traditional tough-on-crime policies.
She is set to take over an office where the last elected district attorney, Richard Brown, a Democrat who died in May after 28 years in office, publicly supported policies associated with quality-of-life enforcement, such as prosecuting subway fare beaters. By contrast, Ms. Katz has talked of importing progressive practices from other boroughs, such as a conviction-review unit, which would examine old cases for possible exonerations.
The victory gives Ms. Katz, the Queens borough president, a chance to implement her own law-enforcement vision after a bruising Democratic primary during which she was labeled a candidate of the establishment while vying with a self-described Democratic socialist public defender, Tiffany Cab?n.
Ms. Katz, who defeated Ms. Cab?n in the primary by 55 votes after a recount of about 90,000 ballots, bristled at the idea that her success wasn?t due to her own ideas and hard work.
She has spent the last few months studying criminal-justice initiatives in Philadelphia, New Jersey and California?places where local officials have experimented with progressive policy changes in recent years. She has had frequent conversations with Eric Gonzalez, Brooklyn?s left-leaning district attorney, and met with law-school deans to discuss recruiting.
?Now it?s on to really starting a job,? Ms. Katz said last week, sitting in her kitchen in the borough?s Forest Hills neighborhood. The home, where she lives with her 8- and 11-year-old sons, has been in her family for 75 years.
Ms. Katz, 54 years old, has never worked as a prosecutor. She spent four years as an associate at law firm Weil, Gotshal and Manges LLP after graduating from St. John?s University School of Law. She spent the bulk of her career in politics, as a member of the state Assembly beginning in 1994, and then the New York City Council from 2002 through 2009. She has been Queens borough president since 2014.
Ms. Katz joins the Queens district attorney?s office at a time when new state laws are requiring major changes.
During Mr. Brown?s tenure, and that of his deputy now in charge, the office followed a more conservative approach, with stricter requirements for guilty pleas, for instance. Mr. Brown was against legalizing recreational marijuana and criticized the plan to close the New York City jail complex on Rikers Island.
Ms. Katz said during her campaign that she would urge lawmakers to legalize recreational marijuana. She supported closing Rikers but criticized the process for building new jails.
The Queens office has also criticized changes to state law going into effect Jan. 1, including one that requires judges to set bail for fewer defendants. On its website, the office has posted a map that shows the locations of 363 crimes allegedly committed by people who are currently in jail awaiting trial but would be free under the new bail policies.
Ms. Katz said the new requirements would help ensure people get both fairness and justice. She said she supported a new law that requires prosecutors to turn over evidence sooner to defense attorneys, saying a good prosecutor could work effectively under those circumstances.
She said her priorities include starting a bureau for housing protection and worksite safety. She said some gun-possession cases could be addressed through alternatives to jail, a view embraced by left-leaning district attorneys.
?I do believe that part of lowering gun violence and lowering crime is to make sure that people never end up in the criminal-justice system in the first place,? she said. (? ? ?)
Still, she said she has a strong sense of justice for victims, citing a driver who killed her own mother when she was 3. ?My whole life was knowing that a criminal act killed my mom,? she said.
Ms. Katz rejected the moniker of establishment candidate and rebuffed the idea that Ms. Cab?n pushed her to embrace progressive policies. ?I?d like to think I pushed her to the left,? Ms. Katz said, adding that she didn?t think Ms. Cab?n, 32 years old, knew about her involvement with progressive ideas, like warrant forgiveness programs, decades ago.
Ms. Katz?s supporters say she is a hard worker with deep ties to the borough.
New York City Councilman Rory Lancman, a Democrat who ran against Ms. Katz in the primary and later supported her, described her as level-headed, even keeled and an experienced manager. In the midst of a heated primary, the two opponents calmly discussed local priorities.
?I was up in her office going over community-board appointments,? Mr. Lancman said.
Write to Corinne Ramey at Corinne.Ramey@wsj.com