Tower Ladders vs Rear Mount straight ladders

jlab

jlab

Joined
May 10, 2019
Messages
495
How doe the powers that be in the FDNY decide whether a ladder company should be assigned a Tower ladder or a rear mount straight ladder ?
 
jlab said:
How doe the powers that be in the FDNY decide whether a ladder company should be assigned a Tower ladder or a rear mount straight ladder ?
Click to expand...
Just a guess but the large majority of battalions in the FDNY have ATLEAST one Tower. I remember seeing something a chief said (I think I could be yapping) that when possible you want a Tower Ladder on your scene. Makes it easier incase you got to go exterior you don't need to wait longer for a TL. Alot safer and easier to make grabs from windows aswell.
 
If I am not mistaken if 3 Sticks are assigned the 4th one is required to be a Tower Ladder. Or maybe it’s the 5th.
 
when they came into the job in the mid 60’s, O’Hagen wanted at least one to be on the report of the 10-30/10-75. Would imagine that location, types of occupancies play into it.
 
The original design by Chief O'Hagan was to have a TL and RM assigned to every box. But of course this is/was not always possible...During the selection process, L 31 was supposed to become a RM, but the Captain (who was buddies with O'Hagan) convinced him to send L 31 a TL, and instead of L 19 being a TL, it became a RM.
 
The attached video shows some great companies doing an outstanding job at a bread and butter job. But it demonstrates some a great aerial device comparison. There is no better airborne fire killer than the aerial scope. There is also no better aerial device for rapid roof access or a single point window grab than the FDNY spec straight stick. Look at the video. At 0:19 TL44 is beginning to drop its tormentors. At 1:19 L27 comes to a complete stop in front of the fire building. 1 full minute behind the TL. At 2:46 ladder 27 is on the roof. At 3:00 both members from L27 and TL 44 transition onto the roof. Well done lads.

 
Always was told tower ladder vs aerial ladder placement had to do with the building in that units first due response area.
 
Nice stop by 92/44, and WOW what a "stop" by 27 truck. Chauffeur dumped the parking brake perfectly.
Fire blowing out the kitchen window?
 
Red dragon said:
Always was told tower ladder vs aerial ladder placement had to do with the building in that units first due response area.
Click to expand...
Not really, the Bronx is made up with the same types of structures whether your in E 45's area, to E 89's area to Hunts Point. H Buildings, TAXPAYER- and row frames. Same as in Brooklyn and Queens. The neighborhood make-up are all the same generally speaking.
 
Every NYC Borough has a lot of tall buildings and sometimes a 75-foot Tower ladder will not reach to the roof. Some FDNY Tower Ladders are 95 feet but not all. So, in tall buildings a 100-foot aerial ladder are often, needed for access to the roof. In advanced fires on lower floors, or shorter buildings the front of the fire building should be kept for Tower Ladder/s, at serious advanced fires. "The front of the building belongs to the truck" and a visible life hazard generally trumps all other considerations. I know money is always a consideration, but FDNY would do well to consider at least one large Tower Ladder, over 100 feet in each Division. The London Fire Brigade in the U.K. has taken delivery of two, 206-foot aerial devices in response a multiple fatality in a London U.K. FDNY TL-18 FF Bob Rainey+Bob Dmartini.jpgTL-18 Feather Factory Fire 1978 or 9.jpgLt. Rainey TL-21.jpgHighrise Dwelling. Toronto Canada has at one 270 ft. Tower Ladder. I spent almost 20 years working in busy FDNY Tower Ladders in the South Bronx and 2 Areas in Manhattan. Nothing is generally better at controlling advanced fires than a properly position and utilized Tower Ladder. Captain Bob Rainey FDNY Engine 26 retired.
 
nothing like climbing the aerial first due roof with everything, and then 2nd due roof just loads his stuff on the TL and gets brought up there like a gentleman lol
 
The big advantage with the older RM was 1 tormentor on the building side and aerial was able to be extended to the roof or wherever needed unless Life was a priority. TL had to have all tormentors extended to raise bucket. We all know speed is necessary for life saving operations. When I left the truck we had a 91 Seagrave 100Ft. and the one tormentor rule was the normal MO.
 
You’re right Tony, it does take a tower longer but the bucket can reach multiple windows and floors for removal if necessary. I worked in both and each has its pluses and minuses. They make for a great fire department.
 
Lt. Q said:
You’re right Tony, it does take a tower longer but the bucket can reach multiple windows and floors for removal if necessary. I worked in both and each has its pluses and minuses. They make for a great fire department.
Click to expand...
R = Rearmount = rescue/Roof
T = Tower Ladder = Tons of water.

LOL. Happy Holidays
 
Agree with Lt. Q, worked on all three types (quickest set up, tiller!)...Now, If you were hanging by your fingernails and a RM and TL showed up at the same time...?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top