I think this is a great idea if staffed by 2 guys from EMS, almost like an ems 'fly car' driving around the boro taking in runs to free up enginesYeah cause if you’re not operating over 30mins then no relocator. What needs to happen maybe for sure if a 3rd due engine can’t be sent or a further engine.
Other Departments like Denver has 2 person crews doing low priority EMS calls so engines are not going to them and more available. Bronx is probably the must impacted Boro with EMS calls (every company is doing over 5,000 runs besides 3 engines.
Anything to take some calls off some of the engines doing so many EMS runs. Truck Companies can’t put out fires with no water…. “Load up on the cans” lolI think this is a great idea if staffed by 2 guys from EMS, almost like an ems 'fly car' driving around the boro taking in runs to free up engines
It's been discussed and was a non starter.Hell, why not just have Ladders start running CFR duty. Not primary, but like second out in busy areas
Look at the shops on any given day. Ladder companies occupy most of the apparatus on the floor. And roughly 140 ladders to 220 engines ( my numbers are not exact but certainly good enough for demonstrative purposes). Ladder companies are much more complex machines than the engine companies ( sensors, hydraulics, electronics etc). They are also quite a bit heavier than engines. So to start running the dog shit out of these beasts and increasing downtime and swap out time is ludicrous and would drive up fleet maintenance costs significantly. The busiest ladder companies ran around 4000 runs in 2023 while the busiest engines ran over 7000. Again, wanna beat these beasts up more? Most importantly the ladders must get into jobs quickly and get positioned on the fire building. There are places in Brooklyn where a ladder is first due to single engine houses in all four map directions. Do you really want to take that unit out of service for a CFR run? The answer is not more FD units to act as first responders. The answer is more EMS units on the streets and a flexible, dynamic , creative EMS delivery system that addresses peak demand hours and daily population shifts across the boros.It's been discussed and was a non starter.
Haha I just posted similar below and then saw your post - that’s the issue no one seems to want to address.Why not increase EMS ?
Please don't think that I was in agreement with Truck Companies going to CFR-D runs. I am not. You touch on all good points and those exact points were actually brought up by members of the discussion group and helped extinguish the idea.Look at the shops on any given day. Ladder companies occupy most of the apparatus on the floor. And roughly 140 ladders to 220 engines ( my numbers are not exact but certainly good enough for demonstrative purposes). Ladder companies are much more complex machines than the engine companies ( sensors, hydraulics, electronics etc). They are also quite a bit heavier than engines. So to start running the dog shit out of these beasts and increasing downtime and swap out time is ludicrous and would drive up fleet maintenance costs significantly. The busiest ladder companies ran around 4000 runs in 2023 while the busiest engines ran over 7000. Again, wanna beat these beasts up more? Most importantly the ladders must get into jobs quickly and get positioned on the fire building. There are places in Brooklyn where a ladder is first due to single engine houses in all four map directions. Do you really want to take that unit out of service for a CFR run? The answer is not more FD units to act as first responders. The answer is more EMS units on the streets and a flexible, dynamic , creative EMS delivery system that addresses peak demand hours and daily population shifts across the boros.
the teacher hasn't been born, who can teach that courseHow about teach people not to call 911 and use the system as their pcp for when they have a “fever/cough”, or nose bleed, or whatever other nonsense they call for
Yes, Disbanded. Went back to the old BLS & ALS ambulance model. All transport vehicles.Wasn't there a Fly Car program for EMS a while back? What ever happened to that.
The concept combined with the relative availability of units were unable keep pace with the city's needs during Covid.Wasn't there a Fly Car program for EMS a while back? What ever happened to that.