Firehouse, Engine Company 305, Hook & Ladder Company 151
The Firehouse, Engine Company 305, Hook & Ladder Company 151 was dedicated on November 15, 1924 in Forest Hills, Queens. The two companies that would occupy the building, Engine Company 305 and Hook & Ladder Company 151, were officially organized on the same day the firehouse opened, assigned to the 46th Battalion, 13th Division of the Fire Department of the City of New York. In contrast to statements made in the early part of the century, by the 1920s, the fire department found there to be a “great need” for new firehouses in this, and other growing Queens neighborhoods. It announced intentions to extend the paid fire department into Forest Hills, and in 1923 it awarded a contract in the amount of $77,713 for construction of a new firehouse on Queens Boulevard. The site for the firehouse appears to have been acquired in 1922, along with sites for firehouses in several other Queens communities, including Bayside, Queens Village, Jamaica, and Jackson Heights, as well as sites for firehouses in Brooklyn and “Westchester.” As noted in the 1924 Annual Report of the FDNY:
The development of certain sections of Brooklyn and Queens has made it imperative to extend the activities of this department. To keep abreast of times it has been necessary to have new firehouses constructed.
Fire loss statistics during this era further underscore the increased need for fire protection throughout Queens, with losses doubling from $1.372 million in 1921 to $2.744 million in 1922.
In contrast to the preceding decades, by the 1920s, the FDNY had transitioned away from commissioning well-known architects to design its firehouses in favor of utilizing in-house staff. In the 1922 Annual Report of the FDNY, in which the approval for construction of several firehouses, including the one in Forest Hills, was discussed, it was noted that the “plans [for the firehouses] have been prepared by the Department and therefore there will be no architect employed in connection with the erection of these buildings.” This was reiterated in the 1924 Annual Report, which announced the completion of several firehouses, including the Forest Hills structure, citing that “the plans and specifications for these buildings have been prepared by this bureau, as has been the practice since this administration came into power, and thus the fees of architects were saved.”
By the 1920s, the Georgian Revival style had became popular for the design of firehouses throughout New York. Employing red brick facades with engaged pilasters, flat roofs, and limestone details, the firehouses of this type were typically compactly massed to conform to the rectangular tax lots of the city. Unlike its contemporaries, Firehouse, Engine Company 305, Hook & Ladder Company 151 was not constructed in the dominant firehouse style of the time. In this way, the design of the Forest Hills firehouse, with its large scale and near-ecclesiastical appearance, is remarkable. The building is designed in a Neo-Medieval style and is prominently located on a corner lot. It features asymmetrical massing accentuated by steep gables clad with copper standing-seam roofs, two prominent square towers (a stair tower and a hose-drying tower) featuring round-arched window openings, and a slender chimney rising nearly a story above the western elevation. The building is strongly suggestive of religious, not civic architecture, particularly in the steep pitch of its roofs and the height of the hose-drying tower, itself reminiscent of a church bell tower. The only aesthetic connection between the Forest Hills firehouse and its contemporaries appears to be the use of similar primary materials – namely red brick and limestone, utilized here to a very different effect.
One explanation for the very different appearance of Firehouse, Engine Company 305, Hook & Ladder Company 151 might be attributed to an evolution in firehouse design that resulted from a shift in requirements. Over the decades, the height of firehouses has been subject to variation, with earlier buildings typically three, or even four, stories in height in order to address the needs of heavily developed areas where land prices made taller buildings more economically viable. However, as fire protection was extended to lower density, suburban areas, such as Forest Hills, lower, less compact buildings became not only possible, but desirable. The taller firehouses meant more opportunities for firemen to be injured sliding on poles, while the shorter firehouses mean fewer flights of stairs to climb or to run. Moreover, once firemen were no longer required to reside full time in the firehouses, different space configurations were required within the buildings. To keep up with advancements in firehouse design, the Forest Hills firehouse was constructed to include a kitchen for the firemen and air-tight doors to “protect the firemen asleep in the dormitory from the danger of gasoline exhaust fumes and to confine the heat to the apparatus floor, so that the motors will always be warm and ready for instant use.” Changes in firehouse requirements alone, however, do not seem to account for the unusual appearance of Firehouse, Engine Company 305, Hook & Ladder Company 151. It is far more likely that the design of the building was the result of efforts to contextualize the new firehouse within the growing residential community of Forest Hills and, in particular, the nearby, renowned planned development of Forest Hills Gardens. In Queens, the firehouses of the earlier century, constructed for the volunteer companies that once protected the borough, were often wood-sided structures with pitched roofs, similarly evocative of residential construction.
Thus, while Firehouse, Engine Company 305, Hook & Ladder Company 151 exhibits an unusual appearance for a firehouse from this time period, it was apparently not unheard of for Queens firehouses to be designed in harmony with their surrounding communities. Though the blocks immediately around the new firehouse were still undeveloped in 1924, nearby Forest Hills Gardens, universally praised for the high-quality of its design, had been completed more than a decade earlier. With the steady, continued development of the neighborhood throughout the 1910s and 20s, it is possible that there was pressure from the surrounding community that the firehouse be designed to the same high standards of the existing development. The small, inward-facing, Tudor Revival style developments of Arbor Close and Forest Close, which are adjacent to the firehouse and were completed shortly following its construction, aesthetically emulate Forest Hills Gardens and seem to similarly point to local pressure for carefully planned development in the Forest Hills neighborhood during this era.
Upon the November 1924 opening of Firehouse, Engine Company 305, Hook & Ladder Company 151, Hubert J. Treacy, chief of the Bureau of Repairs and Supplies for the fire department noted it as “the most pretentious fire engine house in the Greater City.” On the eve of its official dedication, the building was recognized in at least two local papers, the Flushing Evening Journal and the Long Island Daily Star, for having been “constructed to harmonize with the architecture of the surrounding community.” The building was even mentioned several years later, in a 1931 local newspaper article reacting to a pair of apparently unattractive, recently-constructed firehouses which the author notes as “painful to the eye.” The author of the article makes a call for more firehouses in Queens to harmonize with their environments, and mentions only one firehouse – Firehouse, Engine Company 305, Hook & Ladder Company 151 – as an example of how a firehouse “can be good to look upon and in harmony with its surroundings, without the sacrifice of any considerations of usefulness.”
Nearly 90 years after its construction, the Forest Hills firehouse continues to serve as the home of Engine Company 305 and Hook & Ladder Company 151, operating under the motto “Pride of the Hills.” Completed at a time when much of the surrounding area was still in the process of being developed, today the firehouse is at once a striking presence along the Queens Boulevard streetscape and a well-integrated constituent of this vibrant residential neighborhood. It is also an outstanding example of a functional structure whose design also enhances the character of its surroundings. Even as the Forest Hills neighborhood underwent some large-scale redevelopment during the mid-century, the firehouse has experienced very few changes in its appearance. Firehouse, Engine Company 305, Hook & Ladder Company 151 remains a well-preserved, remarkable example of both innovative firehouse architecture, as well as a success story for carefully-considered, forward thinking contextual design.