The location on Union Street at the time seems to be exposure 2 to the quarters of Engine 269.
The firehouse is 788 Union Street, even though I've seen it listed as 786 Union.
The 1940s tax map view looks like it's 788, the same numbers seen today, but it's not clear.
Regardless, exposure 2 to the firehouse is a two-story building both then and now.| NYC Municipal Archives
nycma.lunaimaging.com
Lower District | 77 Canal St, Manhattan | 1869 | with Battalion Chief 8 |
1st Assistant Chief | 77 Canal St, Manhattan | 1883 | |||
1st Deputy Chief | Relocated | 155 (127-129) Mercer St, Manhattan | 1894 | with Ladder 20 |
Division 1 | Organized | 155 (127-129) Mercer St, Manhattan | 1897 | with Ladder 20 | |
Division 1 | Relocated | 173 Lafayette (Elm) St, Manhattan | 1900 | former station Engine 55 | |
Division 1 | Change | 185 Lafayette St, Manhattan | 1905 | from 173 Elm St | |
Division 1 | Renumbered | as Division 2 | 1906 | ||
Division 1 | Reorganized | 193 Fulton St, Manhattan | 1906 | with Ladder 10 | |
Division 1 | Relocated | 100 Duane St, Manhattan | 1907 | with Engine 7 | |
Division 1 | Relocated | 243 Lafayette St, Manhattan | 1938 | with Engine 20 | |
Division 1 | Relocated | 100 Duane St, Manhattan | 1941 | with Engine 7 | |
Division 1 | Temporary | 87 Lafayette St, Manhattan | 1956 | with Engine 31 | |
Division 1 | Relocated | 243 Lafayette St, Manhattan | 1956 | with Rescue 1 | |
Division 1 | Relocated | 42 Great Jones St, Manhattan | 1961 | with Engine 33 | |
Division 1 | New Station | 251 Lafayette St, Manhattan | 1974 | with Engine 13 | |
Division 1 | New Station | 227 Ave of the Americas, Manhattan | 1975 | with Engine 24 | |
Division 1 | Relocated | 251 Lafayette St, Manhattan | 1990 | with Ladder 20 | |
Division 1 | Relocated | 227 Ave of the Americas, Manhattan | 1994 | with Engine 24 | |
Division 1 | Relocated | 251 Lafayette St, Manhattan | 1998 | with Ladder 20 |
Division 1 had its origin in Lower Manhattan in 1869 as the Lower District, coming under command of the 1st Assistant Chief in 1883. In 1906, Division 1 was moved further south to the quarters of Ladder 10 on Fulton Street while Division 2 moved into the former station of Engine 55 on Lafayette Street, splitting the Division area. Division 1 encompasses neighborhoods such as Soho, Tribeca, Little Italy, and Chinatown with buildings from high rises to industrial, residential to ferry terminals, markets, schools and government centers.
Lower District
Lower District 77 Canal St, Manhattan 1869 with Battalion Chief 8
1st Assistant Chief
1st Assistant Chief 77 Canal St, Manhattan 1883 1st Deputy Chief Relocated 155 (127-129) Mercer St, Manhattan 1894 with Ladder 20
Division 1
Division 1 Organized 155 (127-129) Mercer St, Manhattan 1897 with Ladder 20 Division 1 Relocated 173 Lafayette (Elm) St, Manhattan 1900 former station Engine 55 Division 1 Change 185 Lafayette St, Manhattan 1905 from 173 Elm St Division 1 Renumbered as Division 2 1906 Division 1 Reorganized 193 Fulton St, Manhattan 1906 with Ladder 10 Division 1 Relocated 100 Duane St, Manhattan 1907 with Engine 7 Division 1 Relocated 243 Lafayette St, Manhattan 1938 with Engine 20 Division 1 Relocated 100 Duane St, Manhattan 1941 with Engine 7 Division 1 Temporary 87 Lafayette St, Manhattan 1956 with Engine 31 Division 1 Relocated 243 Lafayette St, Manhattan 1956 with Rescue 1 Division 1 Relocated 42 Great Jones St, Manhattan 1961 with Engine 33 Division 1 New Station 251 Lafayette St, Manhattan 1974 with Engine 13 Division 1 New Station 227 Ave of the Americas, Manhattan 1975 with Engine 24 Division 1 Relocated 251 Lafayette St, Manhattan 1990 with Ladder 20 Division 1 Relocated 227 Ave of the Americas, Manhattan 1994 with Engine 24 Division 1 Relocated 251 Lafayette St, Manhattan 1998 with Ladder 20
Battalion 1 | 1869 - 1883 |
Battalion 2 | 1869 - 1883 |
Battalion 3 | 1869 - 1883 |
Battalion 4 | 1869 - 1883 |
Battalion 5 | 1869 - 1883 |
Battalion 6 | 1869 - 1883 |
Battalion 1 | 1883 - 1897 |
Battalion 2 | 1883 - 1897 |
Battalion 3 | 1883 - 1897 |
Battalion 4 | 1883 - 1897 |
Battalion 5 | 1884 - 1897 |
Battalion 6 | 1883 - 1897 |
Battalion 1 | 1897 - |
Battalion 2 | 1897 - 1948, 1951 - |
Battalion 3 | 1897 - 1906, 1948 - 1950 |
Battalion 4 | 1897 - |
Battalion 5 | 1948 - 1950, 1956 - 1974 |
Battalion 6 | 1979 - |
Battalion 7 | 1994 - |
Battalion 19 | 1906 - 1909 |